Game Trailer Makeover - Sheepherds
First-person professional trailer critique
Lieu explains how the Sheepherds trailer improved by giving the basic herding action room to communicate before introducing decoration and extra modes. The early version interrupted action with a title reveal, moved rapidly to customization and showed uniformly successful play, obscuring both the challenge and the game’s depth. The revised sequence demonstrates herding first, then coloring sheep, environmental complications and visible mistakes. This is useful for small teams because the improvement depends on footage selection and sequencing rather than adding features. A trailer can make a modest system understandable by showing its cause, result and variation.
- The revised opening demonstrates herding for 10 seconds.
- Lieu reported over 100,000 IGN views for the revised trailer at publication; no controlled uplift or sales result is supplied.
Use it forDemonstrate the main action immediately. Show difficulty through authentic imperfect play. Introduce extras after the core is understood.
Do not concludeReported views and craft judgments do not establish that the revision increased sales.
Apply in a small-team experiment · 6 steps
Our proposed experiment—not a result measured by this article.
- on day 4, the PM and artist storyboard three shots using one existing mechanic: successful action, complication, and visible recovery; defer customization assets until these shots are readable.
- on day 10, show a silent rough cut to five unfamiliar viewers and ask what the player controls and what makes the task difficult; revise confusing footage before polishing titles.
- Solo: Capture one uninterrupted action and its result.
- Solo: Remove title cards that require insider knowledge.
- 2–5 people: Ask unfamiliar viewers to explain the objective.
- 2–5 people: Sequence basic action, complication and variation before cosmetics.
References & how we used them
2 source references. “Used for” identifies where this page relies on each source; it does not mean the author endorses our interpretation. Historical access notes are not fresh verification.
- Game Trailer Makeover - Sheepherds
Used for: Original article summarized in this research note; hard-data statements retain the source scope
Evidence scope: Trailer communication critique; our production checklist is a separate application. Date follows displayed byline, not URL.
Title and source access checked in this update. Public article text reviewed; linked paid datasets and external announcements not independently audited. Check date: 2026-09-08.
https://www.derek-lieu.com/blog/2026/8/4/game-trailer-makeover-sheepherds - Steam store page — Sheepherds!
Used for: Supporting context; our application steps are separate proposals
Data-page label, not an article title.
https://store.steampowered.com/app/3006280/Sheepherds/
Public full article