When Steam wishlists don't convert: a case study
Historical developer report with analyst interpretation
Power of Ten entered Early Access with roughly twelve thousand wishlists but its developer reported only about three hundred launch-day sales. Carless examines where interest came from: quiet periods produced little daily growth, while festival exposure contributed a large share of the total. The account also includes a player who wished to wait for the finished game. Its value is as a counterexample to treating accumulated wishlists as guaranteed immediate buyers. Teams can use the case to examine baseline demand, campaign cohorts and release expectations while retaining uncertainty about why any particular person did not purchase.
Use it forWishlist totals do not guarantee launch purchases. Campaign spikes need contextual interpretation. Early Access changes some buyers’ timing.
Do not concludeA 2021 anecdote is not a current conversion benchmark or proof that festival wishlists are worthless.
Apply in a small-team experiment · 4 steps
Our proposed experiment—not a result measured by this article.
- Solo: Track normal daily growth between promotional spikes.
- Solo: Ask target players whether they buy Early Access.
- 2–5 people: Prepare low, middle and high launch scenarios.
- 2–5 people: Separate reported conversion from inferred causes.
References & how we used them
1 source references. “Used for” identifies where this page relies on each source; it does not mean the author endorses our interpretation. Historical access notes are not fresh verification.
- When Steam wishlists don't convert: a case study
Used for: Original article summarized in this research note; hard-data statements retain the source scope
Metadata from our earlier source note; not rechecked in this update. Public full article. Check date: 2026-09-08.
https://www.gamedeveloper.com/business/when-steam-wishlists-don-t-convert-a-case-study
Public full article